Skip to content
Stranger Things: The First Shadow artwork

The Stage

Reviewed by Dave Fargnoli · 14 December 2023

4/5

Stranger Things: The First Shadow

Phoenix Theatre, London

“Oscar Lloyd and Isabella Pappas rise brilliantly to the challenge of portraying younger versions of fan-favourite characters Hopper and Joyce.”

A short excerpt from the published review.

More from this review

“Standing out in a strong ensemble, Ella Karuna Williams is by turns tender, tough and resourceful as lonely outsider Patty, chafing against her adoptive father’s strict Christian conservatism and finding surprising common ground with troubled Henry.”

A longer excerpt, as quoted in a published review round-up. Read the full review for the critic's complete verdict.

How it compares: The Stage gave 4★, cooler than most critics. Stranger Things: The First Shadow averages 4.4★ across 9 rated reviews. See them all.

Review © The Stage / Dave Fargnoli. Quoted for the purposes of review and criticism. Source: thestage.co.uk.

The critics' verdict on Stranger Things: The First Shadow

Critics were overwhelmed by the spectacle. Five-star reviews came from the Guardian, the Standard, the Telegraph, WhatsOnStage and London Theatre, all marvelling at the illusions, set-pieces and sheer technical wizardry of Stephen Daldry and Justin Martin's production. Several compared it favourably with Harry Potter and the Cursed Child. The young cast, especially Louis McCartney as Henry and Ella Karuna Williams as Patty, were widely praised. The main reservations were about length and story: Time Out felt it was bloated and tonally uneven, and a few critics suggested it works best for fans of the series.

Stranger Things: The First Shadow: all reviews, dates & tickets

More reviews of Stranger Things: The First Shadow

All 12 reviews
The Interval · Weekly

The week’s best theatre reviews and news, in one email

One email a week combines the best reviews from UK Theatre Reviews with the biggest stories from our sister site, UK Theatre News. You get five-star raves, casting scoops, West End and Broadway transfers and booking deadlines. It’s free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.